| 1961: Carl F. Bayerschmidt, Columbia University | 1992: Joy Renjilian-Burgy, Wellesley College |
| 1962: Edward J. Geary, Harvard Unviversity | 1993: José M. Díaz, Hunter College High School |
| 1963: Harry L. Levy, Hunter College | 1994: Sylvia Brooks-Brown, Baltimore County (MD) Public Schools |
| 1964: Alfred S. Hayes, Center for Applied Linguistics | 1995: Rebecca R. Kline, Penn State University |
| 1965: Wilmarth H. Starr, New York University | 1996: Julia T. Bressler, Nashua (NH) Public Schools |
| 1966: Jean Perkins, Swarthmore College | 1997: Eileen W. Glisan, Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
| 1967: G. Reginald Bishop, Jr., Rutgers University | 1998: Richard Donato, University of Pittsburgh |
| 1968: Robert G. Mead, Jr., University of Connecticut | 1999: Martha G. Abbott, Fairfax County (VA) Public Schools |
| 1969: F. André Paquette, American Council on the Teaching of Foreign Languages | 2000: Frank W. Medley, Jr., West Virginia University |
| 1970: Remunda Cadoux, Hunter College | 2001: Margaret Ann Kassen, Catholic University of America |
| 1971: Hilary Hayden, OSB, St. Anselm's Abbey School | 2002: Don Reutershan, Maine State Department of Education |
| 1972: Mills F. Edgerton, Jr., Bucknell University | 2003: John Webb, Princeton University |
| 1973: Joan L. Feindler, East Williston (NY) Public Schools | 2004: Frank Mulhern, Wallingford-Swarthmore (PA) School District (ret.) |
| 1974: Joseph A. Tursi, SUNY at Stony Brook | 2005: Mikle Ledgerwood, State University of New York at Stony Brook |
| 1975: Jerome G. Mirsky, Jericho (NY) Public Schools | 2006: Nancy Gadbois, High School of Science and Technology, Springfield (MA) |
| 1976: Philip E. Arsenault, Montgomery County (MD) Public Schools | 2007: Marjorie Hall Haley, George Mason University |
| 1977: Jane MacFarland Bourque, Stratford (CT) Public Schools | 2008: Sharon Wilkinson, Simpson College |
| 1978: Thomas H. Geno, University of Vermont | 2009: Laura Franklin, Northern Virginia Community College |
| 1979: Paul D. Cincinnato, Farmingdale (NY) Public Schools | 2010: Jaya Vijayasekar, Vernon (CT) Public Schools |
| 1980: John L. D. Clark, Educational Testing Service | |
| 1981: Helene Zimmer-Loew, New York State Department of Education | |
| 1982: Toby Tamarkin, Manchester (CT) Community College | |
| 1983: John M. Darcey, West Hartford (CT) Public Schools | |
| 1984: June K. Phillips, Indiana University of Pennsylvania | |